Cart

The Firepit

An outdoor lounge experience with spanning ocean views.

The Firepit is an outdoor lounge experience, with spanning ocean views and a menu offering light bites of summer favorites. Guests can relax and enjoy the ocean view during the day over a glass of rosé and oysters, watch the sunset and enjoy the energy of a Montauk night throughout the season. First come, first served. Last call is at 9:30pm due to NYS regulations.

Explore The Menus

A selection of light bites and craft cocktails.

From The Sea

East Coast Oysters

$18 for half dozen / 32 for a dozen

lemon, mignonette, cocktail sauce, horseradish

Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail

$22

cocktail sauce, lemon, horseradish

Lobster Cocktail

$MTK

whole 1.25 lb lobster, cocktail sauce, lemon, horseradish

Seafood Tower

$80

8 oysters / 8 clams / 6 shrimp / 1 lb lobster

8 Oysters / 8 Clams / 6 Shrimp / 1 Lb Lobster

$40

4 oysters / 4 clams / 3 shrimp / 1 1/2 lb lobster

Shareables

Crab Cake

$23

smoked onion remoulade, charleston slaw

Tuna Tostada

$22

marinated tuna, pickled serrano, avocado mousse, scallion, sesame

Avocado Toast

$20

7 grain bread, radish, pea greens, charred lemon vinaigrette

Burrata

$19

yuzu marmalade, olive oil, charred sourdough bread

Artisan Meats & Cheeses

$28

honey comb, marinated olives, grain mustard

Crispy Fried Calamari

$21

sweet chili sauce, peanuts, scallions

Roasted Cauliflower

$18

green harissa aioli, crispy shallots, herbs

Between The Bun

Og Burger

$23

dry aged blend, smoked ranch, LTP, cabot cheddar

Lobster Roll

$35

traditional or warm spicy sriracha

Buttermilk Crispy Chicken

$20

pretzel bun, vinegar slaw, chipotle aioli

Dagwood Turkey Club

$21

avocado, peppers, tomato, bacon, herb aioli, sprouts

Smoked Wagyu Brisket

$22

pickled jalapeños, comete, crispy shallots

Crab Blt

$25

marinated crab, bacon, lettuce. tomato

Pizza

Margherita

$18

san marzano tomato, foir di latte, grana padano, basil

Broccoli Rabe

$20

confit garlic, ricotta, aleppo, fennel sausage

Tartufo

$22

truffle cream, wild mushroom, fior di latte

Cart

An outdoor lounge experience with spanning ocean views.

A selection of light bites and craft cocktails.

Gurney's Star Island Reopens April 30, 2021!