An inviting American kitchen dishing up seasonal classics year-round.

Open daily for breakfast and lunch, Tillie’s offers an approachable menu of American favorites highlighting Montauk produce, served in our Scarpetta Beach venue.

Tillie's dining room shots, and a flat lay of an entree

Explore The Menus

Comfort food at its best.

Morning Specialties
The Bagel Board
brooklyn's acme sliced nova salmon, plain bagel, cream cheese, bermuda onion, beefsteak tomato, capers, radish
Pastry Basket
mini muffins, French donuts, mini croissants
Avocado Toast
smashed avocado, toasted sunflower seeds, radish, Tuscan toast (v) add an egg any style +5 | smoked salmon +10
Morning Specialties
French Toast
fresh raspberries, creme anglaise, toasted almonds, white chocolate mascarpone mousse
Stack Of Pancakes
peach & blueberry compote, warm Amaretto spiked maple syrup
Tillie’s Bowls
Acai Bowl
bananas, fresh berries, house granola (v)
Peaches & Cream
peaches, banana, raspberry, almond butter, honey, maple syrup, vanilla, cinnamon, granola, coconut milk, Greek yogurt
Steel-Cut Oatmeal
brown sugar, dried fruit, blueberries (v)
On The Side
Skillet Potatoes
Applewood Bacon Or Turkey Bacon
Pork Sausage Or Apple Chicken Sausage
Cold Pressed Juices
Green Goddess
pineapple, green apple, kale, ginger
After Party
green apple, carrot, cucumber, beet, lemon, ginger
watermelon, pineapple, lemon, mint
Farm Eggs
Tillie's Breakfast
two eggs any style, bacon & sausage, skillet potatoes, Tuscan toast
Bistro Benedict
poached eggs, smoked Ham, hollandaise, skillet potatoes, grilled Tuscan bread add fresh lobster +14 // lump crab meat +10 // nova smoked salmon +10
Farm Eggs
Bec Sandwich
crispy bacon, two fried eggs, American cheese, buttered poppy seed Kaiser roll
Farmer's Omelet
[choice of 3] onions, peppers, tomato, mushrooms, ham, bacon, goat cheese, white cheddar cheese, gruyere cheese skillet potatoes, Tuscan toast
From The Sea
Raw Bar
small | large lobster cocktail, oysters, clams, lump crab meat, jumbo shrimp
East Coast Oyster
$18 | 36
mignonette, lemon, tabasco
Shrimp Cocktail
jumbo shrimp, cocktail sauce, remoulade
Tuna Tartare
avocado, black garlic soy, crispy shallots, wonton chips
Jus’ Salads
Hot & Cold Caesar
broccolini, boquerones, pecorino toscano, brioche crumb
gem lettuces, avocado, tomato, bacon, egg, smoked buttermilk ranch dressing
Winter Chicory
heirloom apple, caramelized endives, pickled red onion, gorgonzola dolce
Farmer's Greek
cucumber, sweet peppers, tomato, red onions, olives, feta cheese, sumac, lemon vinaigrette
add to any salad: grilled chicken 9 | shrimp 14 | lobster tail 18
Lobster Roll
choice of: traditional or warm spicy sriracha mayo
Dagwood Turkey Club
avocado, pepper, tomato, bacon, lettuce
Grilled Chicken
tomatoes, cucumber, red onion, parsley, tzatziki sauce, naan bread
Og American Burger
smash burger, caramelized onions, American cheese, special sauce
Impossible Burger
white cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, red onion, non dairy cheese optional
Gurney's Dip
shaved prime rib, brandied onion, peppercorn dip
Nashville Hot Chicken
sweet and spicy glaze, coleslaw, pickles
Og Clam Chowder
clams, bacon, Idaho potato
Crispy Sesame Cauliflower
scallions, edamame
Lobster Mac & Cheese
ditalini pasta, parmesan crumbs
Fritto Miso
calamari, fluke, shrimp, fennel, bomba chili
Wagyu Pigs In A Blanket
wagyu hot dog, puff pastry, spicy mustard
Margherita Flat Bread
mozzarella, cherry tomatoes, basil
Bacon & Caramelized Onion Flat Bread
fromage blanc, thyme
Crispy Brussel Sprouts / Fries / Sweet Potato Fries / Broccolini
strawberry coulis
Warm Berry Cobbler
a la mode
Brownie Sunday
walnuts, whip cream, chocolate sauce
Espresso Budino
salted caramel, chocolate biscotti, hazelnut gelato
2 Scrambled Eggs
bacon, breakfast potatoes
brown sugar, blueberries
French Toast
fresh berries, maple syrup
Buttermilk Pancakes
choice of chocolate chip, banana or plain
All Day
Housemade Spaghetti
tomato & basil or butter & cheese
plain or pepperoni
Grilled Chicken Breast
vegetables, mashed potatoes
6 oz chuck blend, american cheese, fries
Turkey & Cheese Sandwich
lettuce, tomato, mustard, mayonnaise, fries
Crispy Chicken Tenders
smoked ranch, chipotle mayo, fries
Vegetables / Mash Potatoes / Fries / Fruit Salad