Cart

Tillie's

An inviting American kitchen dishing up seasonal classics year-round.

Open daily for breakfast and lunch, Tillie’s offers an approachable menu of American favorites highlighting Montauk produce, served in our Scarpetta Beach venue.

Book Now View our menu

Tillie's dining room shots, and a flat lay of an entree

Explore The Menus

Comfort food at its best.

Tillie's Bowls

Acai Bowl

$18

bananas, fresh berries, house granola (v)

Peaches & Cream

$18

peaches, banana, raspberry, granola, Greek yogurt

Steel-Cut Oatmeal

$16

brown sugar, dried fruit, blueberries (v)

Kale & Quinoa Power Bowl

$21

fire roasted vegetables, egg whites, parmesan reggiano, kale, chicken apple sausage, pesto

Morning Specialties

Pastry Basket

$20

assorted mini pastries

Yogurt Parfait

$18

Greek yogurt, seasonal berries, granola

Seasonal Fruit Plate

$18

seasonal melons & berries

Smoked Salmon Board

$22

pastrami salmon, everything bagel, dill spread, tomatoes, capers, red onion

Avocado Toast

$21

smashed avocado, cherry tomatoes, shallot, radish, arugula, citrus vinaigrette add an egg any style +$6 | smoked salmon +$10

Bananas Foster French Toast

$24

brioche, dark rum maple syrup, banana brittle

Buttermilk Pancakes

$22

strawberry rhubarb compote, candied pecans, honey butter, maple syrup

Farm Eggs

Tillie's Breakfast

$22

two eggs any style, choice of bacon or sausage, skillet potatoes, Tuscan toast

Bistro Bendedict

$24

poached eggs, Canadian ham, wilted spinach, hollandaise, english muffin sub fresh lobster +$15 / lump crab meat +$10 /smoked salmon +$10

Farmers Omelet

$23

[choice of three] onions, peppers, tomato, mushrooms, spinach, ham, bacon, goat cheese, white cheddar cheese, gruyere cheese with skillet potatoes, Tuscan toast

Steak & Eggs

$42

skirt steak, fried eggs, potato hash, chimichurri

On The Side

Skillet Potatoes

$10

Applewood Bacon Or Turkey Bacon

$10

Chicken Apple Sausage

$10

Cold Pressed Juices

Green Goddess

$12

pineapple, green apple, kale, ginger

After Party

$12

green apple, carrot, cucumber, beet, lemon, ginger

Sunrise

$12

watermelon, pineapple, lemon, mint

Jamu Juice

$12

ginger, honey, lemon, turmeric, coconut water, black pepper

From The Sea

Raw Bar (Small | Large)

$MKP

lobster cocktail, oysters, clams, lump crab meat, jumbo shrimp

East Coast Oyster

$18 | 36

mignonette, lemon, tabasco

Shrimp Cocktail

$24

jumbo shrimp, cocktail sauce, remoulade

Tuna Tartare

$22

avocado, black garlic soy, crispy shallots, wonton chips

Starters

Og Clam Chowder

$17

clams, bacon, Idaho potato

Crispy Sesame Cauliflower

$17

scallions, edamame

Lobster Mac & Cheese

$35

ditalini pasta, parmesan crumbs

Fritto Miso

$23

calamari, fluke, shrimp, fennel, bomba chili

Wagyu Pigs In A Blanket

$18

wagyu hot dog, puff pastry, spicy mustard

Margherita Flat Bread

$24

mozzarella, cherry tomatoes, basil

Bacon & Caramelized Onion Flat Bread

$25

fromage blanc, thyme

Jus’ Salads

Winter Chicory

$19

heirloom apple, caramelized endives, pickled red onion, gorgonzola dolce

Hot & Cold Caesar

$20

broccolini, boquerónes, pecorino Toscano, brioche crumb

Cobb

$18

gem lettuces, avocado, tomato, bacon, egg, smoked buttermilk ranch dressing

Additions

add to any salad: grilled chicken 9 | shrimp 14 | lobster tail 18

Sandwiches

Lobster Roll

$40

choice of: traditional or warm spicy sriracha mayo

Dagwood Turkey Club

$21

avocado, pepper, tomato, bacon, lettuce

Grilled Chicken Pita

$23

tomatoes, cucumber, red onion, parsley, tzatziki sauce, naan bread

Og American Burger

$26

smash burger, caramelized onions, American cheese, special sauce

Impossible Burger

$28

white cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, red onion, (non dairy cheese optional)

Gurney's Dip

$32

shaved prime rib, brandied onion, peppercorn dip

Nashville Hot Chicken

$23

sweet and spicy glaze, coleslaw, pickles

Sides

Crispy Brussel Sprouts

$12

French Fries

$12

Sweet Potato Fries

$12

Brocolini

$12

Dessert

Cheesecake

$15

strawberry coulis

Warm Berry Cobbler

$16

a la mode

Brownie Sunday

$16

walnuts, whip cream, chocolate sauce

Breakfast

2 Scrambled Eggs

$14

bacon, breakfast potatoes

Oatmeal

$12

brown sugar, blueberries

French Toast

$15

fresh berries, maple syrup

Buttermilk Pancakes

$15

choice of chocolate chip, banana or plain

All Day

Housemade Pasta

$17

tomato & basil or butter & cheese

Pizza

$18

plain or pepperoni

Grilled Chicken Breast

$20

vegetables, potatoes

Cheeseburger

$16

6 oz chuck blend, american cheese, fries

Turkey & Cheese Sandwich

$16

lettuce, tomato, mustard, mayonnaise, fries

Crispy Chicken Tenders

$17

smoked ranch, chipotle mayo, fries

Sides

Vegetables

$11

Fries

$11

Fruit Salad

$11

Book Now

Cart

An inviting American kitchen dishing up seasonal classics year-round.

Comfort food at its best.

Save 25% off at Star Island