Cart

wooden booth at Tillie's with set table

Tillie's

An inviting American kitchen dishing up seasonal classics year-round.

Open daily for breakfast and lunch, Tillie’s offers an approachable menu of American favorites highlighting Montauk produce, served in our Scarpetta Beach venue.

Book Now View our menu

Tillie's dining room shots, and a flat lay of an entree

Explore The Menus

Comfort food at its best.

Cold Pressed Juices
Green Goddess
$14
pineapple, green apple, kale, ginger
After Party
$14
green apple, carrot, cucumber, beet, lemon, ginger
Sunrise
$14
watermelon, pineapple, lemon, mint
Tillie's Bowls
Acai Bowl
$20
bananas, fresh berries, house granola (v)
Steel-Cut Oatmeal
$18
brown sugar, dried fruit, blueberries (v)
Coconut Chia Pudding
$22
brulee banana, shaved coconut, maple syrup, granola, organic berries (v)
Morning Specialties
Yogurt Parfait
$19
Greek yogurt, seasonal berries, granola
Seasonal Fruit Plate
$18
seasonal melons & berries
Smoked Salmon Board
$25
pastrami salmon, everything bagel, dill spread, tomatoes, capers, red onion
Avocado Toast
$25
smashed avocado, cherry tomatoes, shallot, radish, arugula, citrus vinaigrette ( add an egg any style +$6 | smoked salmon +$10)
Buttermilk Pancakes
$24
strawberry rhubarb compote, candied pecans, honey butter, maple syrup
Farm Eggs
Crab Cake Benedict
$36
poached eggs, jumbo lump crab, sauce choron
Lobster Benedict
$42
poached eggs, spinach, local lobster, hollandaise
Farmers Omelet
$26
[choice of three] onions, peppers, tomato, mushrooms, spinach, ham, bacon, goat cheese, white cheddar cheese, gruyere cheese with skillet potatoes, Tuscan toast
Tofu Quinoa Scramble
$28
tofu, heirloom tomato, baby kale, quinoa, avocado, pesto
On The Side
Skillet Potatoes
$12
Applewood Bacon Or Turkey Bacon
$12
Chicken Apple Sausage
$12
From The Sea
Raw Bar (Small | Large)
$MKP
lobster cocktail, oysters, clams, lump crab meat, jumbo shrimp
Chilled Oyster Platter
$21 | 42
mignonette, lemon, tabasco
Shrimp Cocktail
$26
jumbo shrimp, cocktail sauce, remoulade
Tuna Tartare
$30
housemade citrus ponzu, wakame, pickled ginger, avocado, wonton
Starters
Og Clam Chowder
$18
clams, bacon, Idaho potato
Lobster Mac & Cheese
$39
ditalini pasta, parmesan crumbs
Margherita Flat Bread
$24
mozzarella, cherry tomatoes, basil
Fig & Goat Cheese Flatbread
$25
fig jam, whipped goat cheese, balsamic, pickled red onion
Jus’ Salads
Summer Stone Fruit Salad
$22
baby lettuce, grilled stonefruit, feta, heirloom cherry tomato, sunflower seeds, blood orange vinaigrette
Beet & Apple Salad
$21
toasted quinoa, golden raisins, almonds, toasted hemp hearts, arugula, cider vinaigrette
Little Gem Caesar
$21
brioche bread crumbs, parmesan
Sagaponak Farms Summer
$30
house made foccacia, sweet basil oil, tomato salad burrata, balsamico d oro, arugula, north fork sea salt
Additions
$
grilled chicken $12 / shrimp $18 / lobster tail $25
Sandwiches
Lobster Roll
$44
choice of: traditional or warm spicy sriracha mayo
Dagwood Turkey Club
$25
avocado, pepper, tomato, bacon, lettuce
Grilled Chicken Pita
$25
tomatoes, cucumber, red onion, parsley, tzatziki sauce, naan bread
Og American Burger
$28
smash burger, caramelized onions, American cheese, special sauce
Gurney's Dip
$38
shaved prime rib, brandied onion, peppercorn dip
Impossible Burger
$30
white cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, red onion, (non dairy cheese optional)
Vegan Pasta
$28
impossible bolognese, vegan gluten free pene, roasted garlic, vegan mozzeralla, basil
Sides
French Fries
$12
Sweet Potato Fries
$12
Grilled Brocolini
$12
Dessert
Cheesecake
$17
strawberry coulis
Warm Berry Cobbler
$18
a la mode
Brownie Sunday
$18
walnuts, whip cream, chocolate sauce
Cocktails
Mimosa
$18
prosecco, splash of orange juice
Bloody Mary
$21
tito’s vodka, tomato juice, tobasco, citurs, spices
Aperol Spritz
$18
aperol, prosecco, soda
Cucumber Gimlet
$21
botanist gin, cucumber, lime, black pepper
Hibiscus Margherita
$21
hibiscus tinted blanco tequila, lavender agave, lime, floral salt
San Remo
$21
elijah craig small batch bourbon, carpano antico, campari, st. germain, citrus
Caffe Sceccherato
$21
tito’s, espresso, espresso brandy
Breakfast
2 Scrambled Eggs
$14
bacon, breakfast potatoes
Oatmeal
$12
brown sugar, blueberries
French Toast
$15
fresh berries, maple syrup
Buttermilk Pancakes
$15
choice of chocolate chip, banana or plain
All Day
Housemade Pasta
$17
tomato & basil or butter & cheese
Pizza
$18
plain or pepperoni
Grilled Chicken Breast
$20
vegetables, potatoes
Cheeseburger
$16
6 oz chuck blend, american cheese, fries
Turkey & Cheese Sandwich
$16
lettuce, tomato, mustard, mayonnaise, fries
Crispy Chicken Tenders
$17
smoked ranch, chipotle mayo, fries
Sides
Vegetables
$11
Fries
$11
Fruit Salad
$11