Food on table

Eat & Drink

Eat & Drink

Gurney's Star Island has a wide variety of waterfront restaurants – where we believe freshness is key, locality is paramount and flavor reigns supreme.

Award-Winning Pizzas

Il Forno

Translating from Italian to “The Oven,” our Italian Pizzeria & Café, ‘Il Forno’ offers the perfect menu for grab-and-go, as well as in-room dining. Located right off our marina & The Pool Club, Il Forno offers a variety of artisanal coffees and fresh juices, as well as award-winning pizza, sandwiches, and salads. Il Forno is closed for the season and will reopen in 2022!
The Taste of Montauk


A unique spin on east-end dining, Showfish offers an ingredient-driven menu. Fresh fish, ripe vegetables and hand-selected specialties are spun into one-of-a-kind dishes to be enjoyed in a seaside venue with stunning marina views. Showfish is currently closed for the season and will be reopening in March 2022.