Food on table

Eat & Drink

Eat & Drink

Gurney's Star Island has a wide variety of seasonal waterfront restaurants – where we believe freshness is key, locality is paramount and flavor reigns supreme.

Award-Winning Pizzas

Il Forno

Translating from Italian to “The Oven,” our Italian Pizzeria & Café, ‘Il Forno’ offers the perfect menu for grab-and-go, as well as in-room dining. Located right off our marina & The Pool Club, Il Forno offers a variety of artisanal coffees and fresh juices, as well as award-winning pizza, sandwiches, and salads.
The Taste of Montauk


A unique spin on east-end dining, Showfish offers an ingredient-driven menu. Fresh fish, ripe vegetables and hand-selected specialties are spun into one-of-a-kind dishes to be enjoyed in a seaside venue with stunning marina views.
Sip, Swim & Relax

The Pool Club

In the summertime, The Pool Club at Gurney’s Star Island Resort & Marina is the ideal place to sip, swim, and relax. Overlooking our 232-slip marina, The Pool Club supplies all the comforts necessary for a leisurely day in the sun. Relax on one of our waterfront chaise lounges, or enjoy one of signature frozen drinks. Indulge in our poolside food menu, with options including our famous traditional or spicy sriracha lobster rolls, smoked brisket, and more.
Star Island

In-Room Dining

Enjoy a wide selection of breakfast, lunch and dinner items delivered straight to your room! Dial extension 1177 to order.